ARNOLD "ARNIE" ROTH is
a fictional character appearing in American comic books published
by Marvel Comics. The character was created by writer J. M.
DeMatteis and artist Mike Zeck and first appeared in Captain America #268,
published in April 1982. Arnie is a childhood friend of Steve Rogers,
the civilian identity of the costumed superhero Captain America. Decades
later, the pair are reacquainted after Arnie is targeted by Captain
America's adversaries Helmut Zemo and the Red Skull. Later in his life,
Arnie would assist with the "Captain America Hotline" created to field
tips pertaining to national security before dying of bone cancer
.Marvel Comics
editor-in-chief Jim Shooter instituted a "No Gays in the Marvel
Universe" policy in the 1980s, in response to public backlash against a
scene in The Hulk #23 (1980) in which Bruce Banner is accosted and threatened with rape by two men at a YMCA. LGBT expressions in comic books were also restricted by the Comics Code Authority, a system of comic book content regulation. Consequently,
the sexual orientation of LGBT characters in comics published by Marvel
could for many years only be communicated through subtext, as in the
case of Northstar in Alpha Flight, and Mystique and Destiny in Uncanny X-Men.
Arnie was the
first openly gay character to appear in a mainstream superhero comic.
The character was conceived by DeMatteis as part of his effort to
develop Captain America's supporting cast and explore how the character
"had surrounded himself with people who represented American diversity",
though as a result of editorial dictates at Marvel and the restrictions
of the Comics Code Authority, DeMatteis was forced to communicate
Arnie's sexuality exclusively through imagery and subtext. Though the
tragic bent of stories featuring the character has been the subject of
criticism, he has been praised as a positive media representation of gay
men in the context of a 1980s media landscape characterized by
homophobia and backlash against gay men amid the HIV/AIDS crisis.
Arnie Roth made his first appearance in Captain America #268
(April 1982) as an unnamed pedestrian who happens to see Steve Rogers
on a date with Bernie Rosenthal. He is formally introduced in Captain America #270 (June 1982), where he is retroactively established as Steve's childhood friend. Arnie departed Captain America in issue #306 (June 1985) and would not return until Captain America #428
(June 1994), written by Mark Gruenwald and drawn by Dave Hoover. The
character would continue to make appearances in the comic until his
death in Captain America #443 (September 1995). Stuart Vandal of The Appendix to the Handbook of the Marvel Universe speculated
that the character's death was likely a consequence of
Marvel's floating timeline, and the reality that it was increasingly
implausible for a character born in the 1920s to be alive in stories set
in the modern era.
Arnie has appeared occasionally in flashbacks to Steve's past. In 2012, he appeared in Captain America volume 7, issue 3 written by Rick Remender and penciled by John Romita Jr., and in 2024 appeared in Avengers Academy: Marvel Voices #21 written by Anthony Oliveira and penciled by Carola Borelli.
Easton notes that
the relationship between Arnie and Steve "reverses stereotypes while
reinforcing those of hegemonic masculinity", noting that while as
children Arnie takes the traditionally masculine role as Steve's
protector, as adults it is the "soft, less fit, and more vulnerable"
Arnie who must be protected by Captain America. Tabak
similarly notes how this role reversal and Arnie's awareness of Captain
America's secret identity repurposes "imagery and language of the
closet and of coming out [...] towards a superhero's own 'closeted'
identity", noting how "invoking that similarity between the superhero
experience and that of gay men in America serves to enrich the bond
between Arnie and Steve".